Security Threats and Fragile Commitments: Stress-Testing Public Support for Human Rights at Home and Abroad

Research question/goal: 

One bulwark against democratic backsliding is a strong citizen commitment to defending human rights. But how strong is that commitment among European publics? This project offers a detailed two-part answer. First, it maps public attitudes to human rights across the continent with a novel cross-national survey in 25 European countries, exploring the depth and strength of these attitudes as well as broader public understandings and expectations of human rights. Second, with a detailed experimental investigation in two major European countries (Germany and the UK), we stress-test public support against security threats and explore how commitment to rights can be strengthened. Our experiments are embedded into a major two-wave panel survey. In the first stage of the experiment, we distinguish between a political threat posed by a potential terrorist attack from either a far right or an Islamist group and a non-political threat posed by Covid-19. We vary the source and content of the threat message, testing hypotheses about the role of social media and inflammatory rhetoric in driving threat perceptions. In the second stage, we analyse whether and how this heightened sense of insecurity affects attitudes towards human rights. A further experiment tests whether messages calling either for strengthened security or for a defence of human rights affect support for these rights. We focus on attitudes towards two civil liberties that are key to a lively democracy but have increasingly come under pressure: freedom of the press and right to assembly.

This is a joint project with Robert Johns (University of Essex) and Katrin Paula (Technische Universität München).

Current stage: 

After having secured DFG funding, we have hired Nadine O’Shea as postdoctoral researcher, who has taken up the position on 1 November 2023 and is based at the Technical University of Munich (TUM). We are currently developing our survey measures and experiments for threat perceptions, for the policy proposals that are meant to constrain specific certain rights to tackle the specific threats, and for the normative and instrumental treatments for bolstering human rights support. The research design for this first major part of our project will be presented to international experts on this topic at a workshop in Mannheim in April 2024.

Fact sheet

Funding: 
DFG
Duration: 
2020 to 2026
Status: 
ongoing
Data Sources: 
cross-national survey and experiment
Geographic Space: 
Europe, Germany, Italy, Poland and the UK

Publications